Time to Ponder

How does one react to a terror-attack that makes one’s country the focus of international news for three days when the capability of the country to handle the attack hangs in balance? How does one react to the news of death-in-the-terror-attack of a distinguished batchmate, Hemant Karkare, the ATS Chief?

The whole nation is angry. The anger is generated by a sense of helplessness and a widespread belief that nothing much may happen in the wake of the attack. The nation feels helpless because the strings that move the terrorists are beyond our borders and located in a country which does not feel contrite about the blatant nature of the terrorist act and whose leaders by their glib statements inspire no confidence of greater control over the terrorists. Statements by our national leaders that a fitting reply will be given for all terrorist acts are not taken seriously by the citizens, because such assurances in the past have not been followed up with “appropriate steps”, and, what is even more serious, the appropriate steps bring in its wake the possibility of a war with a nuclear power which has not shown signs of possessing a conscience. The utter frustration that results finds expression in anger.

A large nation with high-tech capabilities and an emerging economy sits fretting and fuming. Someone questions how a lathi-wielding constable could have matched up with a terrorist. Would that someone like the lathi-wielding constable to carry AK-47s to handle the routine crowds? Another raises questions about the reason for not guarding hotels. One wonders whether business can flourish if all customers from abroad are subjected to strict physical searches. In hindsight such searches may make sense, but would they be considered good commercial strategy before the incident had occurred?

Obviously, the people of India are confronted with a situation where they are not able to think of clear-cut and easy solutions. When one is confused, one feels frustrated and angry. Mumbai attacks have virtually brought trained warriors of a sworn enemy into our streets to shoot down innocent and unarmed people. But should the entire country be turned into a battlefield by arming and training every constable to fight battles with such trained soldiers? For a highly trained and desperate group, the options for perpetrating the terror-violence are limitless. Should the administration start preparing itself for all the limitless possibilities? Would that not reduce the country to a pauper which spends all its resources on fighting terror-wars? Is that not exactly what the enemies of our nation are aiming for? Should the entire police force of a city be taken away from their routine duties of providing relief to the common man from crimes by local criminals and put on endless high alert?

Obviously, this is not the solution we wish for. And yet, right now the fear psychosis of another attack somewhere else, with perhaps more barbarity, is a nightmare that makes people think of such desperate solutions. The planners will have to act fast to provide solutions that give the citizens a sense that the Indian nation can act in the face of challenges.

Meanwhile, what should we as the citizens of a hurt nation do? Is there nothing other than anger and criticism that we can adopt as our individual response to the occurrence?

Let us resolve that we will

work with greater sincerity and focus to achieve better results in whatever we undertake as individuals and groups;

bring up our children as constructive achievers, free of backbiting and petty squabbling;

avoid doing all those acts which might bring us temporary gains but cause damage to the system;

constantly strive to make ourselves more capable and more efficient individuals;

associate with and assist others who are working for the improvement of the system;

reduce our wants and enjoy simplicity of living with high ideals.

Let us become KARMAYOGIs.

Advertisement

4 Responses to “Time to Ponder”

  1. Amitabh Thakur Says:

    Sri Dogra sir,

    Your Article “Time to ponder” has assessed the effects and impact of the Mumbai incidence in which we all lost one of your batchmates Sri Karkare, taking in its purview not only the police department and the government machinery but also the entire Nation in its totality. Yes, as you have said, there is a need to “work with greater sincerity” and “associate with and assist others who are working for the improvement of the system”. Again, reducing our wants, our requirements and our self-needs is no less important for the simple reason that these things are so-closely related to our functioning. And this holds true not only for our own department but for every Indian, whichever sphere of life he is associated with.

    Amitabh Thakur,
    SP(Intll),
    Faizabad
    # 94155-34526

  2. dogrask Says:

    Thanks Amitabh. What we call response to a situation is not necessarily what the Home Minister does or what the Government of Maharashtra does. The national response to a situation of this type is made up of all the little responses by everyone in the nation— in the same way as the mighty ocean is made up of small drops. If all of us become a force as individuals and as groups, the nation will be a mightier force to face external aggression than it is now.

    Thanks for supporting my idea of self-improvement as a response to the attack.

  3. akash awasthi Says:

    Dear Dogra Sir,

    Finally I found the space to visit you here. And you have discussed here topics that are troubling my conscience too…though not as Akash, but as an Indian, as a human being, as the many other roles we all play in the daily course of our life. What is our future? Again, future of not only Akash, but all the roles mentioned above. We are losing our freedom due to this dastardly acts of chaos-mongers. I am also being stopped and frisked randomly everywhere. The fact that I am always an “outsider” in every state, makes me a more valid candidate for the duty-fulfillment of these security people whether they be the CISF or the Civil Police or the Private Security at various institutions.

    My point of view is holistic because I am a common man like billions in this country. Probably they are going through it too. And I scream within myself searching for a reason why peoples’ freedom is now slightly curbed. I understand Terrorism, the genocides, the emotions of the perpetrators, the helplessness of the system in containing this situation, almost every involved component in this unfortunate episode. But in all this understanding, I am sacrificing too much of my freedom because none of these understand me(a very common citizen). I continue to live in bounds.

    I have not much idea about the running of the system, but my mind innocently thinks that a better intelligence can prevent these localised incidents that cripple our country as a whole, because we don’t know where it’ll happen next. An administrator who is worth his salt knows that one of his prime duties is to keep life panic-free for the people, while he struggles with the direst of threats. Today, the panic is wide-spread. Our administration is failing in its prime job.

    I wish we had officers like you everywhere in the country so that we are not so impotent in handling the issues our country faces from time to time.

    It’s always a learning experience for me no matter how many times or how long I talk to you. I am committed to do my deeds in my life in line with your principles.

    MAGICIAN AKASH

  4. dogrask Says:

    Akash, Thanks for your good words about me. Today’s world is becoming more and more complex and solutions sometimes elude even those who are very sincere about finding them. Technology makes it possible for one single individual with nasty intentions to destroy thousands of people. If each one of us spends some time every day cleansing his or her heart, the complexion of the society will change sooner or later.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.